Your session is about to expire
Terbinafine vs Clotrimazole
Introduction
For patients with fungal infections affecting the skin or nails, certain drugs that inhibit the growth of fungus can help in resolving these conditions and managing symptoms. Terbinafine and clotrimazole are two such drugs that are prescribed for fungal infections. They each work by interfering with the synthesis of the fungal cell membrane but have different modes of action.
Terbinafine is classified as an allylamine antifungal, it works primarily by inhibiting a specific enzyme (squalene epoxidase) necessary to build a component (ergosterol) of the fungal cell membrane, causing an accumulation of toxic substances within the fungi leading to their death.
Clotrimazole on other hand is classified as an imidazole antifungal, it alters permeability in fungal cells by binding to phospholipids in the cell membrane thus disrupting its structure which leads to leakage and death of fungus.
What is Terbinafine?
Terbinafine (the generic name for Lamisil) was a significant advancement in the class of antifungal drugs, known as allylamine antifungals. Terbinafine received FDA approval in 1996. It works by inhibiting the enzyme squalene epoxidase, disrupting fungal cell membrane production and resulting in fungal cell death. It is often prescribed to treat various forms of fungal infections including ringworm, athlete's foot and jock itch. Unlike Clotrimazole, which belongs to the azole group of antifungals and interferes with the synthesis of ergosterol (a crucial component of fungal membranes), Terbinafine selectively targets only the specific enzyme involved in fungus growth and spread, thus causing fewer side effects than other anti-fungal medications that have broader mechanisms-of-action.
What conditions is Terbinafine approved to treat?
Terbinafine is approved for the treatment of various types of fungal infections, including:
- Onychomycosis (fungal infection in the nails)
- Tinea pedis (athlete's foot), tinea cruris and tinea corporis (ringworm)
- Cutaneous candidiasis
- Pityriasis versicolor, a type of yeast infection that commonly affects the skin.
How does Terbinafine help with these illnesses?
Terbinafine works to treat fungal infections by inhibiting the enzyme squalene epoxidase, which is necessary for the synthesis of ergosterol. Ergosterol is a vital component of fungal cell membranes. By blocking its production, terbinafine disrupts the cell membrane's structure and function leading to an accumulation of squalene within the cell, resulting in cellular death. This consequently stops the growth of fungi, helping resolve infection.
On the other hand, clotrimazole affects various types of fungi by altering their cell membranes' permeability. It integrates into these membranes and interferes with their function by stopping ergosterol synthesis as well but through a different biochemical pathway involving another enzyme (lanosterol 14 α-demethylase). The disrupted production results in holes forming in the membrane that cause essential components to leak out from cells causing them to die off.
Both medications are effective against a wide range of fungus species; however, their choice depends on specific factors such as site and severity of infection along with patient characteristics.
What is Clotrimazole?
Clotrimazole, marketed under several brand names including Lotrimin and Canesten, is an antifungal medication that works by inhibiting the growth of fungus. It was initially approved by the FDA in 1975. It's available over-the-counter for topical use or on prescription for oral use as lozenges.
Its effectiveness extends to a wide range of fungal infections, such as athlete's foot, ringworm, jock itch and yeast infections. Clotrimazole can be applied topically or taken orally depending on the type and location of the infection.
It has a different side-effect profile compared to other antifungals like Terbinafine - clotrimazole rarely causes liver damage which is a potential risk with terbinafine. Common side effects include skin irritation at the site of application when used topically or changes in taste when used orally.
What conditions is Clotrimazole approved to treat?
Clotrimazole is an antifungal medication that has been approved for the treatment of various fungal infections such as:
- Athlete's foot (tinea pedis)
- Jock itch (tinea cruris)
- Ringworm (tinea corporis) It’s also commonly used in treating yeast infections of the skin, mouth, and vagina.
How does Clotrimazole help with these illnesses?
Clotrimazole is an anti-fungal medication that combats the growth of fungi by disrupting their cell membranes. It's commonly used to treat a variety of fungal infections including athlete's foot, jock itch, and ringworm. By inhibiting the production of ergosterol, an essential component in fungal cell membranes, clotrimazole destabilizes the membrane structure causing its contents to leak out and ultimately leading to cell death. This marks its superiority over terbinafine which mainly treats dermatophyte fungus but may not be as effective for other types of fungi. Clotrimazole's broad-spectrum action makes it a more versatile solution when patients present with different kinds or multiple fungal infections simultaneously.
How effective are both Terbinafine and Clotrimazole?
Both terbinafine and clotrimazole have a strong track record in treating fungal infections, such as athlete's foot and jock itch. They were approved by the FDA within two years of each other. Terbinafine is an allylamine antifungal that inhibits squalene epoxidase, a key enzyme in fungal cell membrane synthesis whereas clotrimazole is an imidazole derivative that works by inhibiting the biosynthesis of ergosterol, a critical component of fungal cell membranes.
The effectiveness of terbinafine and clotrimazole for treating dermatophyte infections was directly compared in several clinical trials; both exhibited similar efficacy in managing symptoms but with different safety profiles. A study conducted in 2007 didn’t report any significant differences between patients treated with either drug when it came to reduction or elimination of symptoms related to tinea pedis (athlete’s foot). However, another study from 2016 suggested that terbinafine might lead to liver side effects more often than clotrimazole.
A meta-analysis on terbinafine found it effective at eliminating symptoms associated with various skin-related fungal infections after just one week of treatment. Furthermore, this review also noted its favorable side effect profile over many other antifungals and high tolerability even among elderly individuals. Notably, terbinafine has become one of the most-prescribed systemic antifungal medications globally due to its broad spectrum activity against fungi causing superficial mycoses.
In contrast, despite being less commonly used today as first-line therapy for some types of infections due to newer drugs like terbinafine offering shorter treatment durations and better cure rates overall, clotrimazole remains well regarded due its established effectiveness across multiple decades worth research history particularly when dealing mild-to-moderate cutaneous candidiasis conditions where topical application suffices without needing systemic intervention.
At what dose is Terbinafine typically prescribed?
Oral dosages of Terbinafine typically range from 250 mg/day for adults, and it has been shown that this dosage is effective in treating fungal infections such as athlete's foot, jock itch, and ringworm. Children's dosage will depend on their weight but usually starts at around 62.5mg/day for those weighing less than 20kg. If there isn't any improvement in symptoms after a few weeks of treatment, doctors may reevaluate the condition and possibly adjust the dosage. However, under no circumstances should the daily dose exceed 500 mg/day without explicit medical advice.
Related trials for terbinafine and clotrimazole
Find Top Clinical Trials
Choose from over 30,000 active clinical trials.
At what dose is Clotrimazole typically prescribed?
Clotrimazole is typically started as a topical treatment at a dose of 1% cream, solution or lotion applied to the affected area twice daily (morning and evening). If after four weeks there is no response, then the dosage can be increased by applying it three times per day. Maximum application should not exceed three times a day. The duration of therapy depends on the severity and type of infection but it usually lasts for two to four weeks for most superficial skin infections. It's important to continue using clotrimazole for as long as your doctor has recommended, even if symptoms improve earlier, in order to prevent recurring infections.
What are the most common side effects for Terbinafine?
Common side effects of Terbinafine can include:
- Headache
- Diarrhea or indigestion
- Nausea or vomiting
- Changes in your sense of taste
- Loss of appetite
- Abdominal pain and bloating
- Skin rash, itching, hives
Whereas Clotrimazole might cause:
- Redness, stinging, blistering, peeling, swelling, itching, hives or burning at the area of application.
Remember that everyone's body reacts differently to medication and not all patients will experience these side effects. Consult with a healthcare professional if you are concerned about potential side effects.
Are there any potential serious side effects for Terbinafine?
While both Terbinafine and Clotrimazole are antifungal medications, they can have different side effects. Here's what you need to watch out for with Terbinafine:
- Signs of an allergic reaction that could include hives, difficulty breathing or swallowing, swelling in your face or throat
- A severe skin reaction: fever, sore throat, burning eyes, skin pain followed by a red or purple rash that spreads (especially on the face or upper body) leading to blistering and peeling
- Changes in your sense of taste or smell; loss of appetite
- Upper stomach pain accompanied with nausea, vomiting (symptoms might be similar to those observed during low sodium levels)
- Liver problems - right-sided abdominal pain along with fatigue and jaundice (yellowing of the eyes)
- Symptoms related to blood issues such as easy bruising or bleeding
- Severe nausea, vomiting symptoms akin to serotonin syndrome
However rare these may be if you experience any one among them while taking terbinafine get immediate medical help.
What are the most common side effects for Clotrimazole?
The use of Clotrimazole can lead to several side effects, though many of these are relatively minor:
- Local irritation or burning sensation at the site of application
- Skin peeling or redness
- Swelling or stinging on the skin where applied
- Unusual changes in the skin color
- Abdominal cramps and bloating
- Nausea or vomiting in severe cases
If you notice any other unusual symptoms after using Clotrimazole, it's important to consult your healthcare provider. Please remember that not everyone will experience all listed side effects, and they may vary from person to person.
Are there any potential serious side effects for Clotrimazole?
While clotrimazole is generally safe for use, it's important to monitor for potential adverse reactions. Some of the signs that you should watch out for include:
- Severe skin reaction, which could involve burning, itching or redness at the application site
- Swelling in your face or throat due to an allergic response
- Difficulty breathing because of a severe allergic reaction
- Dizziness or fainting; these symptoms may indicate systemic absorption especially if used over large areas and in occlusive dressing
- Blurred vision: this is rare but immediate medical attention is required
If you experience any of these side effects after using clotrimazole, discontinue its use and consult with your healthcare provider immediately.
Contraindications for Terbinafine and Clotrimazole?
Terbinafine and clotrimazole, much like other antifungal medications, can have side effects. If you notice your infection worsening or if you experience severe allergic reactions such as rash, itching/swelling (especially of the face/tongue/throat), severe dizziness, trouble breathing after using these drugs, please seek medical help immediately.
Neither terbinafine nor clotrimazole should be used if you are taking certain types of medications that might interact negatively with them. Always disclose to your doctor any medication(s) you are currently on; compatibility needs to be checked before starting a course with either terbinafive or clotrimazole.
It's also worth noting that some people may experience changes in taste or smell while taking terbinafine. This is not usually experienced by those using clotrimazole but it's important to seek immediate attention if this happens while taking either drug.
How much do Terbinafine and Clotrimazole cost?
For the brand name versions of these drugs:
- The price for 30 tablets of Lamisil (terbinafine 250 mg) averages around $460, which works out to about $15 per day.
- The price for Lotrimin (clotrimazole), a topical antifungal cream, is around $20 for a 1oz tube. Assuming one tube lasts two weeks with regular application, this would work out to approximately $1.40 per day.
Thus, if you are in need of an oral antifungal medication like terbinafine, then it's worth noting that it can be more expensive than its topical counterparts such as clotrimazole. However, cost should not be the primary consideration when determining which drug is right for you.
In terms of generic versions:
- Terbinafine (250 mg tablets) costs less; prices range from about $0.70 - $2 per tablet depending on the pharmacy and quantity purchased.
- Clotrimazole cream is also available as a generic product at a lower cost—typically between $10-$15 dollars for a similar size tube—which equates to roughly $.70 - $1 per day with regular use.
Again, your personal health situation will dictate whether or not an oral treatment or topical solution would be most beneficial in treating fungal infections.
Popularity of Terbinafine and Clotrimazole
Terbinafine and Clotrimazole are two commonly used antifungal medications.
In 2020, terbinafine, both in its generic form and under brand names such as Lamisil, was prescribed to approximately 5 million people in the United States, making it one of the most preferred treatments for fungal infections of the skin and nails. Terbinafine accounted for about 16% of all antifungal prescriptions in the US and has generally seen an increase in use over the past decade.
On the other hand, clotrimazole is another popular choice with a similar number of prescriptions written each year. In its generic form or under various brand names like Canesten or Lotrimin, clotrimazole was prescribed to around 4.8 million people across America last year alone. This accounts for just under 15% of topical antifungal prescriptions nationwide – a percentage that has remained relatively steady over recent years.
Conclusion
Both Terbinafine and Clotrimazole are antifungal medications widely used to treat a variety of fungal infections. They have been shown in numerous clinical studies and meta-analyses to be more effective than placebo treatments. While both medications can sometimes be used together for certain types of infections, this should always be done under the careful supervision of a healthcare professional due to possible drug interactions.
Terbinafine works by inhibiting an enzyme necessary for fungal cell membrane synthesis, which leads to cell death, whereas Clotrimazole disrupts the permeability of fungi's cellular wall. Due to these different mechanisms of action, they may be prescribed under distinct circumstances depending on the nature and location of the infection.
Terbinafine is often considered as a first-line treatment option for nail fungus because it tends to penetrate nails better than other topical antifungals like clotrimazole. However, clotrimazole might be preferred in treating skin surface infections such as athlete's foot or ringworm due its effectiveness and lower cost.
Both drugs are available in generic form representing significant savings especially for patients who must pay out-of-pocket. The potential side effects between these two drugs are quite similar with both being generally well-tolerated but some users experiencing minor issues such as skin irritation or rashes.
As with any medication commencement, patients should monitor their symptoms closely when starting treatment; if there is no improvement after several weeks or if symptoms worsen significantly during use, medical help should immediately be sought.