Maxalt vs Fioricet

Listen to the article instead of reading through it.


For patients suffering from migraines, certain medications can help manage and alleviate the intense pain associated with these severe headaches. Maxalt and Fioricet are two such drugs that are commonly prescribed for this purpose. They each have different mechanisms of action but both aim to provide relief from migraine symptoms.

Maxalt or rizatriptan belongs to a class of drugs called triptans which work by narrowing blood vessels in the brain, stopping pain signals from being sent to the brain, and blocking the release of certain natural substances that cause pain, nausea, and other symptoms of migraines.

Fioricet on the other hand is a combination drug composed of acetaminophen (a pain reliever), butalbital (a barbiturate) and caffeine. It works by reducing inflammation which could be contributing to your headache while simultaneously relaxing muscle contractions in blood vessels to improve blood flow.

It's important to consult your healthcare provider before starting either medication as they may not be suitable for everyone due their potential side effects or interactions with other medications.

What is Maxalt?

Rizatriptan (the generic name for Maxalt) is a drug of the triptan class which has been designed for the treatment of migraines. It was first given approval by the FDA in 1998. Maxalt works by narrowing blood vessels around the brain and affects certain nerves in the brain to relieve headache, pain, and other migraine symptoms such as sensitivity to light/sound and nausea. It operates more specifically than Fioricet on serotonin receptors with minimal effect on other neurotransmitters.

On the other hand, Fioricet combines three ingredients: butalbital (a barbiturate), acetaminophen (Tylenol), and caffeine. This combination helps reduce fever, ease pain, and promote muscle relaxation — making it an effective choice against tension headaches rather than migraines specifically. The presence of different compounds results in a broader range of effects but also potential side effects including dependency due to butalbital.

What conditions is Maxalt approved to treat?

Maxalt has been approved by the FDA to treat acute migraine headaches in adults:

  • With or without aura (a sensory phenomenon or visual disturbance)
  • Migraine attacks lasting 4 hours or longer
  • In combination with other over-the-counter medications for managing nausea and sensitivity to light and sound

On the other hand, Fioricet is utilized primarily for tension headaches caused by muscle contractions. It may also be used off-label for migraines, but it's not approved specifically for this use.

How does Maxalt help with these illnesses?

Maxalt helps to manage migraine symptoms by stimulating serotonin (5-HT1) receptors in the brain. It does this by mimicking the action of serotonin, causing constriction of the blood vessels and reducing inflammation - which are considered major contributors to migraine headaches. Serotonin is a neurotransmitter that plays an important role in mood, sleep patterns, pain perception and other bodily functions. Migraines have been linked with decreased levels of serotonin during attacks; therefore, by increasing its activity Maxalt can limit the negative effects of migraines and help patients manage their condition.

On the other hand, Fioricet addresses tension headaches through a combination effect: Its acetaminophen component relieves pain; caffeine increases the effectiveness of acetaminophen while also constricting enlarged blood vessels that may lead to headaches; butalbital reduces anxiety and promotes relaxation. Each component contributes differently yet synergistically for relief from tension-type headache.

What is Fioricet?

Fioricet is a brand name for a combination drug that includes butalbital, acetaminophen and caffeine. Butalbital belongs to the class of drugs known as barbiturates, which have sedative effects. This means it can help to reduce anxiety and induce relaxation by slowing down the central nervous system. The inclusion of acetaminophen helps in pain relief while caffeine works by stimulating the central nervous system, reducing fatigue and improving alertness and productivity.

Fioricet was first approved by the FDA in 1984. Unlike Maxalt, which specifically targets migraines through its action as a selective serotonin receptor agonist (triptan), Fioricet has more general application for tension headaches due to its different mechanism of action on multiple pathways in the body.

Side effects differ from those typically seen with triptans such as Maxalt: they include drowsiness or lightheadedness rather than sensations of tingling/numbness/prickling/heat etc., flushing or feeling hot; these are common side-effects associated with triptans like Maxalt. The unique blend of ingredients found in Fioricet makes it an effective choice for patients who do not respond well to “typical” migraine specific drugs like Maxalt.

What conditions is Fioricet approved to treat?

Fioricet is a combination medication that has been approved for treating various types of conditions, such as:

  • Tension headaches
  • Muscle contraction headaches This drug works by combining the effects of acetaminophen (a pain reliever), butalbital (a barbiturate to help with anxiety and promote relaxation), and caffeine (which can improve the effectiveness of the analgesic).

How does Fioricet help with these illnesses?

Fioricet is a combined medication that includes butalbital, acetaminophen, and caffeine. It plays a role in many processes of the body to manage tension headaches due to muscle contractions. Fioricet works by relaxing muscle contractions involved in tension headaches through the sedative effects of butalbital, while acetaminophen acts as a pain reliever, and caffeine aids in enhancing the pain-relieving effects by improving blood flow. The action on these different pathways makes Fioricet effective for tension headache relief. Since it does not significantly affect serotonin levels like triptan drugs such as Maxalt (used primarily for migraines), it is often prescribed when patients do not respond well to typical migraine medications or may be used in combination with other treatments if advised by a healthcare provider.

How effective are both Maxalt and Fioricet?

Both rizatriptan (Maxalt) and Fioricet have established histories of providing relief to patients suffering from migraines, although they were approved by the FDA at different times, with Maxalt receiving approval in 1998 while Fioricet has been available since the 1980s. These drugs work differently: Maxalt is a selective serotonin receptor agonist that constricts blood vessels in the brain to relieve swelling, whereas Fioricet combines butalbital (a barbiturate), acetaminophen and caffeine to reduce pain signals sent from nerves.

A randomized control trial conducted in 2001 comparing rizatriptan with other triptans demonstrated its efficacy as a powerful option for acute migraine treatment. The study also indicated promising safety profiles among patients who took this drug. In another study published in 2013, no significant differences were found between patients taking rizatriptan or other related medications regarding their ability to alleviate migraine symptoms completely.

As per a systematic review on various analgesics for primary headaches done in 2004, it was found that combination drugs like Fioricet can be effective at relieving tension-type headaches and migraines. However, due to potential side effects such as dependency resulting from long-term use of barbiturates like those present in Fioricet, it's often recommended only when other first-line treatments are ineffective or not tolerated well by the patient.

A recent meta-analysis review conducted in 2016 showed that while triptans like Maxalt appear more effective than placebo or non-specific alternative medications for treating acute migraine attacks; they're typically thought of as second-line treatment options after over-the-counter NSAIDs fail. Notably though, there are certain circumstances where these might prove better choices - such as instances where quick onset of action is critical or if nausea/vomiting precludes oral medication usage.

Despite being highly effective at relieving headache pain short-term , chronic usage of medicines containing barbiturates like Fioricet may lead towards physical dependence and could result into 'rebound' headaches – ultimately making headaches worse rather than better over time.

abstract image of a researcher studying a bottle of drug.

At what dose is Maxalt typically prescribed?

Oral dosages of Maxalt typically range from 5–10 mg per dose, and it's advised to not exceed more than 30 mg in a 24-hour period. The lower dosage of 5 mg is usually beneficial for treating acute migraine attacks in most patients. Adolescents aged between 12-17 are often started on the same dosage as adults. In contrast, Fioricet is generally administered as one or two tablets every four hours as needed for pain relief, not exceeding six tablets per day. It's essential that these doses shouldn't be increased without consulting with your healthcare provider first due to risk factors associated with each medication.

At what dose is Fioricet typically prescribed?

Fioricet therapy is usually initiated with one or two tablets every four hours as needed, not to exceed six tablets in a 24-hour period. The dosage represents a combination of butalbital (50mg), acetaminophen (325mg) and caffeine (40 mg). It's essential not to increase the dose without consulting your healthcare provider. Therefore, if there's no significant improvement in symptoms after the initial doses, you should contact your doctor for further advice. Remember that Fioricet can cause dependency if used frequently or over extended periods; hence it should be used strictly under medical supervision.

What are the most common side effects for Maxalt?

Common side effects of Maxalt include:

  • Dizziness
  • Nausea and vomiting
  • Weakness or tiredness (asthenia)
  • Dry mouth
  • Sensations of tingling, prickling, or numbness (paresthesias)

Patient using Fioricet may experience the following common side effects:

  • Drowsiness (somnolence)
  • Lightheadedness
  • Feeling anxious or restless (anxiety) -Dizziness -Nausea, upset stomach, constipation; -Dry mouth; -Sleep problems such as insomnia.

Always remember to consult with a healthcare provider for any concerning symptoms.

abstract image of a patient experiencing side effect

Are there any potential serious side effects for Maxalt?

Maxalt, like any medication, carries a risk of side effects, though most people do not experience severe ones. In rare cases however, serious side effects can occur:

  • Signs of heart attack: chest pain or pressure; pain spreading to your jaw or shoulder; sweating; nausea
  • Stroke symptoms: sudden numbness or weakness (especially on one side of the body), sudden severe headache, slurred speech
  • High levels of serotonin in the body - agitation, hallucinations, fever, fast heart rate, overactive reflexes
  • Heart rhythm problems: racing heartbeat and shortness of breath that may lead to dizziness and fainting spells
  • Allergic reactions signs: hives; difficulty breathing; swelling in your face or throat

Fioricet comes with its own set of potential risks:

  • Liver disease symptoms: loss of appetite leading to rapid weight loss yellowing eyes/skin (jaundice)
  • Symptoms related to high amounts of caffeine in the system such as restlessness and insomnia.

If you experience any such severe reactions while taking either Maxalt or Fioricet seek immediate medical attention.

What are the most common side effects for Fioricet?

Fioricet, a medication often prescribed for tension headaches, may cause side effects such as:

  • Dry mouth or an unpleasant taste
  • A feeling of being drunk (alcohol intoxication)
  • Difficulty sleeping (insomnia)
  • Upset stomach, nausea and vomiting
  • Increased urination
  • Shaking or tremors
  • Lightheadedness and dizziness
  • Sweating excessively
  • Rapid heart rate or palpitations It's important to note that Fioricet has potential for misuse due to the presence of butalbital, a barbiturate. On rare occasions it can also lead to confusion or agitation. It is highly recommended you consult with your healthcare provider before starting this medication.

Are there any potential serious side effects for Fioricet?

While Fioricet is generally well-tolerated, it can occasionally cause serious side effects. If you experience any of the following symptoms, seek medical attention immediately:

  • Signs of a severe allergic reaction such as hives; difficulty breathing; swelling of your face, lips, tongue, or throat
  • Symptoms related to liver problems like upper stomach pain, loss of appetite, dark urine or jaundice (yellowing of the skin or eyes)
  • Shortness of breath
  • A seizure (convulsions)
  • Fast or irregular heartbeats
  • Mental / mood changes such as agitation or hallucinations
  • Extreme weakness and drowsiness

Remember that these potential side effects are rare but should be taken seriously if they do occur while taking Fioricet.

Contraindications for Maxalt and Fioricet?

Both Maxalt and Fioricet, along with many other migraine medications, may cause rebound headaches if used too frequently. If you find that your migraines are becoming more frequent or severe, it's crucial to seek medical attention right away.

Maxalt should not be taken if you have consumed ergotamine-containing or ergot-type medications (such as dihydroergotamine or methysergide) within the 24 hours preceding the attack. The same goes for any other triptan-based medication due to increased risk of serotonin syndrome. Similarly, Fioricet cannot be mixed with certain substances such as monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs). These drugs must clear from your system over a period of about two weeks before starting treatment with Fioricet to avoid potentially dangerous interactions.

Always disclose all current medication use to your healthcare provider in order to prevent harmful drug interactions and side effects.

How much do Maxalt and Fioricet cost?

For the brand name versions of these drugs:

  • The price for 12 tablets of Maxalt (10 mg) averages around $550, which works out to about $45/day, depending on your dose.
  • The price for 30 capsules of Fioricet is approximately $110, working out to roughly $3.60/day.

Thus if you are taking dosages in the higher range for Maxalt (two doses per day), then brand-name Fioricet would be less expensive on a per-day treatment basis. However, it's important to remember that cost should not be the primary consideration when determining which drug is right for you.

When considering generic versions of these medications:

  • Generic Maxalt (rizatriptan) can cost between $15 and $50 per tablet or between $30 and $100 daily if taking two doses per day.
  • Generic Fioricet costs around $.75 -2.25$ /tablet , so if you take up to six pills a day as recommended maximum dose it could cost from approximately $.75 -13.5$/day .

As always with medication decisions, consult with your healthcare provider about what option is best suited to treat your medical condition safely and effectively.

Popularity of Maxalt and Fioricet

Rizatriptan, also known by its brand name Maxalt, is commonly prescribed for the treatment of acute migraine attacks. In 2020, it was estimated that approximately 1.2 million people in the US were prescribed rizatriptan. This accounted for around 7% of all triptan prescriptions in the country. Rizatriptan has seen a steady increase in prevalence since its approval by the FDA in 1998.

Fioricet, on the other hand, containing a combination of butalbital (a barbiturate), acetaminophen and caffeine is typically used to treat tension headaches rather than migraines. It was prescribed to an estimated number of just over one million people in America during 2020 accounting for about 3% of total analgesic prescriptions related with headache disorders. The use Fioricet has been relatively stable over the past decade despite concerns regarding potential dependency due to its barbiturate content.


Both Maxalt (rizatriptan) and Fioricet have a long history of use in treating migraines and tension headaches, respectively. They are backed by numerous clinical studies indicating their efficacy surpasses that of placebo treatments. Due to their different mechanisms of action, with Maxalt primarily acting on serotonin receptors to constrict inflamed blood vessels in the brain causing migraines, while Fioricet is a combination medicine used for tension headaches caused by muscle contractions involving butalbital (a sedative), acetaminophen (a pain reliever), and caffeine (to increase the effectiveness of acetaminophen).

Maxalt would usually be considered as first-line treatment option for migraine sufferers where over-the-counter drugs fail or aren't suitable; Fioricet may be prescribed when other headache treatments are not effective or can’t be used.

Both medications come in generic forms representing significant cost savings particularly for patients who pay out-of-pocket. The onset time varies with both drugs: Maxalt typically starts working within 2 hours; Fioricet's effects may occur sooner but it requires careful monitoring due to its potential addiction risk.

The side effect profile is somewhat similar between these two medications — generally well tolerated — but they carry unique risks too. For instance, rebound headaches are common if either drug is taken frequently or over long periods whereas serious heart problems could arise from using Maxalt too often. Patients should closely monitor any unusual symptoms especially when starting treatment, and must seek medical help immediately if conditions worsens or new symptoms emerge.